The Case of the Missing Oil
A Chanukah Heist by Samuel Black and Rabbi Amy Josefa Ariel
I have a student who is a fantastic story teller with an amazing sense of humor. Last week, we got to talking and over about 40 minutes sketched out a Chanukah story that we realized really needed to be told. We dug in . . . and told it. Samuel gave me his blessing to share it with you. Actually he said, "Oh yeah. Share it. This is a story that people will want to read."
Happy Chanukah!
Chapter 1: A Very Empty Corner
The Maccabees had won the war, scrubbed the Temple, and rebuilt the altar. There was just one small problem.
"The oil," said the High Priest, staring at an empty corner of the storeroom. "It was right here. Pure oil. Sealed. Enough to light the Menorah for months. Now there is only this small jar, just enough for tonight!"
The crowd gasped. Someone fainted. Someone else fainted on the person who had fainted.
"Send for Shmuel the Detective!" the Maccabees cried.
Shmuel the Detective arrived with parchment, a quill, a very large hat, and the squinty look of a man who had already solved three crimes before breakfast. He crouched in the corner and began to sniff around.
"Hmm," he said.
"Nu? What do you see?" asked the High Priest.
“Hmmm,” he said. He plucked something small and round from the floor. "A Greek coin. Somebody was in a hurry."
He frowned. "Spilled oil," said Shmuel, dabbing a finger in a shiny puddle. "And these." He followed a trail of enormous, round footprints out the door. "Hmmmm,” he said. “Elephant tracks. Why would anyone bring an elephant to a robbery?" The detective stroked his long beard. "Aha! Because they were carrying something heavy!” Hmmmmmmm."
"Is that one a good hmm or a bad hmm?" asked the High Priest.
"The best kind," said Shmuel the Detective. "The kind that means I'm on the case. I’ll just get some sleep, and then I’ll start following those tracks first thing in the morning."
“Well,” said the High Priest, “We’d better light that oil while we have it.”
And they did.
Chapter 2: Two Very Helpful Soldiers
The following morning, the elephant tracks, and a trail of dripping oil, led Shmuel to the edge of the Assyrian Greek camp. Behind a pile of empty wine jugs, two soldiers were waving swords at each other and singing very badly.
This was Demetrius and Adad, the lowest-ranking soldiers in the entire Assyrian Greek army. They had never been promoted, never been praised, and never, not once, been invited to the general's tent.
Until now.
Shmuel put on a pair of fake glasses.
"Excuse me," said Shmuel, in his friendliest voice. "I seem to have lost my elephant. I’ve been following her tracks, and they end here. Have you seen her?"
Demetrius hiccuped. "Elephant? We don't know anything about an elephant."
"Nothing at all," said Adad. “We don’t know anything about oil, either,” he said, winking so hard that his whole face scrunched up.
"But if we did know," said Demetrius, leaning in, "we'd say it went that way.” He pointed south.
"It’s like we told the general," said Adad. "It was our idea. Mostly mine."
"It was mine!"
"It was not!"
They drew their swords and began to duel, which in their condition meant a lot of wobbling and a very close call with a tent pole.
"Careful!" warned Shmuel. "You'll poke an eye out!"
"We never poke eyes out!" said Demetrius, poking at the air three feet to the left of Adad.
Shmuel thanked them, tipped his big hat, and set off to the south.
He walked for an hour. Then he stopped.
"Hang on," he said. "They were drunk. Why am I listening to them?"
He turned around.
Chapter 3: The Great Soldier Squabble
Back at the camp, Demetrius and Adad were now hugging and weeping and singing and going on about how much they loved each other.
"Gentlemen," said Shmuel the Detective, "I've just heard the most terrible news."
"What news?" asked Adad, his eyes wide.
"The general says that only one of you can get the medal for the oil idea. He asked me to find out whose idea it really was."
The hugging stopped.
"It was mine," said Adad. "I said, 'Demetrius, let's take the oil to Ptolemais!'"
"Ptolemais?" said Demetrius. "That was my idea! I said we should hide it in Akko! You wanted to put it in a sock!"
“Only while we travelled. I hide lots of things in my socks. But you called the city by its Jewish name. That city doesn’t even exist anymore,” snorted Adad.
"Akko," said Shmuel, writing it down on his parchment. "Thank you, gentlemen. You've both been very helpful." He tipped his hat, and started out again, north this time, just as the sun was setting. “I supposed I’d better find somewhere to sleep tonight,” he sighed.
Chapter 4: Elephants, Elephants Everywhere
The trip to Akko took five days, and Shmuel the Detective did not enjoy a single one of them. His third night on the case he slept in an empty sukkah in someone’s field and it rained. The fourth night he found a nice family to take him in, but it turned out they were a family of sleep talkers and sleep walkers and he didn’t have a moment’s peace! The fifth night he decided to just keep walking, and that was all well and good until a pack of jackals scared him half to death. The sixth night he was so tired he was very nearly ready to give up when an old woman welcomed him to sleep in her barn. To be fair, he slept all right, but when he woke up all of her unmarried relatives were standing over him and sizing him up. He tipped his hat, thanked the woman, and as quickly as he could went on his way. The seventh night wasn’t as bad as it could have been. He found a crevice in some rocks to protect himself from the wind and slept on the beach. The next day he had a stiff neck, but the sunrise over the mediterranean sea had been lovely.
When he finally reached the Assyrian Greek garrison, he found it swarming with guards. He could not walk in the front gate. He could not climb the walls. He could not even sneak past the soldiers eating lunch, because they were sitting directly in front of the gate.
Then he heard it: the loud, grumbling trumpet of unhappy elephants.
"Elephants," he whispered. "Of course."
An elephant pen had been erected at the edge of the camp. Shmuel crept up, slid open the latch, and patted the smallest elephant on the trunk.
"Go make some good trouble,” he whispered, “then run for freedom!"
The elephants stampeded into the camp. Soldiers shrieked. Tents flew. Someone's lunch ended up on someone else's head. While every guard ran in circles, Shmuel strolled past them and slipped through the gate, tipping his hat to no one in particular.
Chapter 5: Into the Tunnels
Inside the fortress, Shmuel searched every storeroom and cellar. No oil. Then, behind a rickety wooden door, he found a narrow staircase leading down. And down. And down.
The tunnels were dark and twisty and damp, and Shmuel was soon completely lost.
"Left," he muttered. "No, right. No, left. Was that left?"
A shape flashed down the corridor ahead of him: a soldier in chain mail with a red cross on his left shoulder . . . very out of place.
"Hey!" Shmuel the Detective ran after him, skidded around the corner, and found nothing but a bare stone wall.
"Must have been a shadow," he said. He did not notice the faint, faraway sound of a heavy sword clanking off into a different century.
What he did hear was another sound.
Meeeehhhh.
"Goat?" said Shmuel. "Okay. Cool. I like goats."
A small brown goat trotted around the corner and stared at him.
"I'm lost," Shmuel told the goat. He dug in his pocket for some of the hay from the barn. “Would you like a little nosh?” The goat happily munched on his offering. “So little goat? Nu? Maybe you know the way to go?"
The goat turned and trotted off. Shmuel the Detective followed it through one tunnel, then another, then a third, until the goat stopped in front of a heap of old sacks. Behind the sacks sat rows and rows of jugs, all sealed, all shining faintly in the dark.
"The oil," breathed Shmuel. "You found the oil!"
"Hey!" called a voice. "You've got my goat!"
Chapter 6: The Shepherd
A tall, white haired shepherd in a plain robe the same color as the goat came down the tunnel, leaning heavily on a long staff and breathing hard. He had kind eyes and a smile that looked like he knew a joke nobody else had heard yet.
"I'm so sorry," said Shmuel the Detective. "Your goat was helping me solve a case."
"He does that," nodded the shepherd. "Tell you what. You return my goat, and I'll help you with your oil."
"There are dozens of jugs," said Shmuel, “that will take . . .”
The old shepherd snapped his fingers.
The jugs vanished.
Shmuel's mouth fell open. "What did you...?"
"Shall we?" said the shepherd, and he led the way up a staircase Shmuel had never seen before. They walked together into the sunlight, where a wagon was waiting, piled high with jugs of oil and hitched to a patient donkey.
"But," said Shmuel, "How..."
"Never mind that," said the shepherd, handing him the reins. "Off you go. It’s time for you to get back. Jerusalem is that way."
Shmuel the Detective climbed aboard thinking about the five day journey ahead of him. Then turned back to the shepherd and said, "I never caught your name."
"I never caught yours," said the shepherd.
"Shmuel," said Shmuel. “I’m a detective.”
"I’m sure you are." The shepherd smiled.
Then the shepherd, who some have known as Elijah, disappeared.
Chapter 7: The End of the Eighth Day
The trip from Jerusalem to Akko had taken five very long days and even longer nights. The trip from Akko to Jerusalem took five hours. Shmuel decided not to think too hard about it.
Back in the Temple, the Menorah was sputtering. The oil that was only enough for one night had miraculously lasted for eight, but it seemed their miracle was running out. The last drops of oil flickered in the lamp, and the crowd that had gathered was starting to panic. Some people began to cry quietly. Some people began to wail. Where is Shmuel the Detective with our oil? They all wondered.
Just then, the great doors banged open.
In rolled Shmuel, dusty and sunburned. His big hat was crooked, and he was grinning. “That’ll do, Bernice,” he said to the donkey. The people saw that the wagon was full of jugs of oil.
"Hooray!" cried the crowd.
Just before the flame went out, on the ninth night after they’d sent Shmuel the Detective off to find the missing oil, the High Priest poured in the fresh oil. The Menorah blazed up, bright and golden, and every face in the Temple glowed.
"It’s another miracle!” exclaimed the High Priest.
“What happened?" everyone asked. "Where was it? Who took it? Why?"
So, what else?
Shmuel told them everything. The coin, the spilled oil, the elephants, the duel of the drunken soldiers, the stampede, the tunnels, the goat, and the shepherd who snapped his fingers. He left out any mention of the woman’s many unmarried relatives.
When he finished, they gave him food and drink and a very comfortable cushion, so he could have a nice, long, and well-earned rest.
Nearby, two people who had listened to the whole megillah looked at each other.
"Wow," said one. "That was a great story."
"Yeah!" said the other. "We should write a book about it!"
The End.